Best Movies of Birds Soaring Through Cinemas Skies

Finest films of birds takes flight, providing a singular lens by means of which to discover the cinematic world. From the earliest flickering frames, filmmakers have been captivated by the avian realm, reworking feathered creatures into stars of the silver display screen. These aren’t simply documentaries; they’re tales woven with wings, beaks, and a contact of Hollywood magic, providing tales of journey, drama, and the sheer marvel of flight.

Contemplate the origins: the spark of inspiration, the technical improvements, and the storytelling evolution that has elevated birds from background surroundings to central characters.

This exploration dives into the evolution of hen illustration in cinema, uncovering the historic context and early examples that set the stage for future productions. We’ll uncover iconic characters, dissect the genres which have embraced avian themes, and look at the artistry of bird-inspired visuals. Moreover, the challenges and triumphs behind the scenes of bird-themed filmmaking might be revealed. This journey by means of cinema’s skies isn’t just about leisure; it is a examine in creativity, innovation, and the enduring fascination with the creatures that share our planet.

Discovering the Cinematic Universe of Feathered Associates and their Huge Display Adventures

The silver display screen has lengthy been captivated by the pure world, and few topics are as visually placing and symbolically wealthy as birds. From majestic eagles hovering by means of the sky to the standard sparrow flitting by means of city landscapes, these creatures have supplied filmmakers with a wealth of narrative prospects. The fascination with avian characters in cinema did not emerge in a single day; it is a journey rooted in early cinematic methods, evolving storytelling approaches, and a rising understanding of the pure world.The preliminary spark for bird-centric films might be traced again to the early days of cinema, a interval characterised by technological limitations and a nascent understanding of storytelling.

The need to seize the sweetness and dynamism of birds on movie was intertwined with broader tendencies in early filmmaking. Documentaries and nature movies, which had been among the many earliest types of cinematic leisure, usually featured birds as topics. These movies, whereas usually rudimentary of their technical execution, laid the groundwork for future productions. Early filmmakers had been captivated by the birds’ actions and talent to seize the viewers’s consideration.

Whereas avian cinema gives a flock of implausible movies, generally you crave a distinct type of expertise. Fascinated about a top-tier cinematic expertise, maybe you are trying to find the final word in consolation and high quality? In that case, contemplate testing the best odeon luxe derby for a very immersive film evening earlier than returning to the fantastic world of feathered mates on the large display screen.

As movie know-how superior, so did the potential to painting birds in additional advanced and fascinating methods. Early examples explored the pure behaviors of birds, utilizing them to characterize ideas like freedom, peace, or hazard. The straightforward visible spectacle of birds in flight, coupled with their inherent symbolism, made them a pure match for cinematic exploration. The evolution of animation additionally performed a vital function.

From the majestic eagles hovering by means of the skies to the quirky penguins waddling on ice, the world of avian cinema gives a pleasant escape. Think about catching these feathered stars on the large display screen, maybe after a fast journey to vue cinema blackburn for a pre-movie snack, earlier than immersing your self within the drama and marvel of one of the best films of birds.

Animators rapidly realized the potential to create fantastical and expressive hen characters, which additional expanded the probabilities of bird-themed cinema. Early animated movies, akin to these produced by pioneers like Walt Disney, showcased the appeal and enchantment of hen characters, cementing their place within the cinematic panorama. These early movies, although easy by in the present day’s requirements, established a basis upon which subsequent filmmakers would construct, making a wealthy and numerous cinematic universe of feathered mates.

Early Fowl-Themed Movies and Their Impression

Early movies exploring the world of birds had been instrumental in shaping how audiences perceived and appreciated these creatures. They supplied glimpses into their lives and behaviours, usually with a mix of documentary realism and imaginative storytelling. These movies, whereas restricted by the know-how of the time, captured the general public’s creativeness and paved the way in which for future productions.Listed below are some examples of early bird-themed movies:

  • The Eagle’s Nest (1908): This early silent movie, one of many earliest identified examples of bird-themed cinema, doubtless documented the habits of eagles. The movie’s affect was in its novelty, showcasing the great thing about eagles in flight and their nesting habits. It was a pioneering effort that launched audiences to the visible potential of bird-centric storytelling.
  • The Birds’ Christmas Carol (1913): Based mostly on the favored story, this early adaptation introduced a heartwarming narrative involving birds, doubtlessly in symbolic roles or as companions to the characters. Its reputation stemmed from its sentimental story and use of birds as a thematic ingredient.
  • The Gold Rush (1925): Charlie Chaplin’s iconic movie features a memorable scene that includes a hungry Chaplin cooking and consuming his shoe. The movie’s affect lay in its masterful mix of comedy and pathos, and the inclusion of birds, even when solely in passing, helped to humanize the expertise.
  • Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (1937): Whereas not solely centered on birds, this animated basic from Disney options birds as integral characters, helping Snow White and interacting with the setting. The movie’s widespread enchantment was as a consequence of its groundbreaking animation, memorable characters, and fairy-tale storytelling.
  • Fantasia (1940): This groundbreaking animated movie integrated birds in a number of segments, together with “The Ceremony of Spring” and “Dance of the Hours,” showcasing their actions and incorporating them into summary visible narratives. The movie’s affect got here from its formidable fusion of animation and classical music, and its use of birds in evocative, usually surreal, methods.
Launch Yr Temporary Plot Abstract Key Parts of Reputation
1908 Seemingly documented the habits of eagles, showcasing their nesting habits and flight. Pioneering effort that launched audiences to the visible potential of bird-centric storytelling, novelty.
1913 A heartwarming narrative, doubtless based mostly on a preferred story, that includes birds in symbolic roles or as companions to the characters. Sentimental story and use of birds as a thematic ingredient.
1925 Charlie Chaplin’s iconic movie features a memorable scene that includes a hungry Chaplin. Masterful mix of comedy and pathos, humanizing the expertise.
1937 Animated basic that includes birds as integral characters, helping Snow White and interacting with the setting. Groundbreaking animation, memorable characters, and fairy-tale storytelling.
1940 Groundbreaking animated movie integrated birds in a number of segments, showcasing their actions and incorporating them into summary visible narratives. Bold fusion of animation and classical music, and its use of birds in evocative, usually surreal, methods.
See also  Posters of Horror Movies A Deep Dive into Visual Terrors

The Affect of Technological Developments on Fowl Portrayal

Technological developments have revolutionized the way in which birds are portrayed in cinema, resulting in extra real looking, visually beautiful, and emotionally resonant representations. Early movies relied on sensible results and rudimentary animation methods, which, whereas revolutionary for his or her time, had been restricted of their means to seize the nuances of avian conduct and look.The appearance of computer-generated imagery (CGI) marked a major turning level.

CGI allowed filmmakers to create extremely detailed and lifelike hen characters, able to performing advanced actions and interacting seamlessly with live-action environments. This opened up an unlimited array of prospects, from recreating the refined actions of feathers to depicting birds in dynamic flight sequences. The usage of movement seize know-how additional enhanced the realism of hen characters. By capturing the actions of actual birds or human actors, filmmakers might create animations that had been extremely correct and plausible.

The power to render environments in higher element additionally contributed to the realism of hen portrayals. Trendy particular results allowed for the creation of beautiful landscapes, which enhanced the general visible affect of bird-centric scenes. The combination of CGI and sensible results additionally allowed filmmakers to mix realism with creativeness. Movies likeThe Lord of the Rings* trilogy, which used CGI extensively to carry fantastical creatures to life, demonstrated the ability of this strategy.

Moreover, developments in animation methods, akin to improved rendering and animation software program, have enabled animators to create hen characters with higher expressiveness and emotional depth. These developments should not merely about visible spectacle; in addition they allow filmmakers to inform extra advanced and compelling tales about birds. This progress has led to movies that aren’t solely visually spectacular but in addition deeply shifting and thought-provoking.

Unveiling Iconic Fowl Characters

Best Movies of Birds Soaring Through Cinemas Skies

The cinematic panorama is peppered with unforgettable characters, and amongst them, birds have soared to iconic standing. These feathered protagonists and supporting gamers transcend mere animal portrayals, changing into symbols of freedom, resilience, and even villainy. Their enduring enchantment lies in a potent mixture of compelling personalities, narratives that resonate deeply, and visible illustration that captivates audiences of all ages.

Defining Memorable Avian Performances

The creation of an iconic hen character hinges on a number of key parts. A well-defined persona is essential. Is the hen brave, crafty, comical, or merciless? Their motivations, the driving forces behind their actions, should be clear and compelling. Do they search freedom, revenge, companionship, or maybe merely a great meal?

The affect on the narrative is paramount; these characters ought to affect the plot, form different characters’ destinies, and depart an enduring impression on the viewer. A really memorable hen character embodies these traits, changing into an integral a part of cinematic historical past. They usually function allegories for human experiences, exploring themes of survival, belonging, and the complexities of the pure world.

Examples of Iconic Fowl Characters

The next examples illustrate the enduring affect of avian characters in movie. Their memorable qualities have cemented their place in standard tradition.

  • Zazu ( The Lion King, 1994):
  • Species: Purple-billed hornbill.

    Qualities: Zazu is a perpetually exasperated, but loyal, majordomo. His humor and fixed makes an attempt to maintain Simba in line present comedic aid and a grounding presence amid the drama of the Delight Lands. His unwavering dedication to the royal household and his witty observations make him an indispensable a part of the narrative. Zazu’s character gives a comedic stability to the extra severe tones of the movie, and his function within the narrative demonstrates the significance of accountability.

  • Hedwig ( Harry Potter collection, 2001-2011):
  • Species: Snowy owl.

    Qualities: Hedwig represents loyalty, companionship, and a hyperlink to the magical world. Her silent presence and unwavering devotion to Harry, even within the face of hazard, embody a deep emotional connection. The owl’s magnificence and style make her a visible image of the marvel and thriller of the wizarding world. Hedwig’s sacrifice within the last movie emphasizes the themes of loss and the significance of relationships.

  • Woody Woodpecker ( Woody Woodpecker collection, 1940-present):
  • Species: Pileated woodpecker (stylized).

    Qualities: Woody’s manic power, distinctive snigger, and mischievous antics have made him a cartoon icon. He’s an emblem of rebel and a gleeful disruptor of the established order. His slapstick humor and irreverent angle have entertained generations, and his memorable snigger has develop into immediately recognizable. Woody’s character represents the anarchic spirit of cartoons, and his enduring reputation proves the enchantment of the underdog.

  • Blu ( Rio, 2011):
  • Species: Spix’s macaw.

    Qualities: Blu’s journey from domesticated hen to a free-flying member of his species is a coming-of-age story. His awkwardness, his preliminary incapability to fly, and his eventual overcome adversity make him relatable and endearing. Blu’s character demonstrates the significance of embracing one’s true nature and discovering belonging. His story emphasizes themes of household, conservation, and the great thing about the pure world.

    In the case of one of the best films that includes birds, audiences usually search charming narratives and beautiful visuals. Whereas avian-themed movies provide numerous tales, the cinematic panorama additionally options actors like Israel Broussard, whose filmography gives a distinct perspective on storytelling; try israel broussard movies to discover his numerous roles. Finally, one of the best hen films present a singular cinematic expertise, charming viewers with each compelling plots and memorable performances.

  • Iago ( Aladdin, 1992):
  • Species: Purple-shouldered macaw.

    Qualities: Iago is a comedic villain, a sarcastic and grasping parrot who serves as Jafar’s sidekick. His sharp wit, exaggerated expressions, and high-pitched voice present a counterpoint to Jafar’s extra severe demeanor. Iago’s loyalty to Jafar and his function within the villain’s schemes make him an integral a part of the battle. His character gives comedian aid and illustrates the hazards of greed and blind allegiance.

Cultural Significance and Lasting Affect

These avian characters have resonated with audiences throughout generations as a consequence of their relatability and the profound themes they embody. They usually characterize common human experiences: loyalty (Hedwig), the battle for freedom (Blu), the triumph of the underdog (Woody Woodpecker), or the complexities of excellent and evil (Iago). These characters have impressed merchandise, theme park sights, and numerous imitations, demonstrating their lasting affect on standard tradition.

See also  Penrith Movie Cinema A Cinematic Journey Through Time and Innovation

They’ve additionally contributed to elevating consciousness in regards to the significance of hen conservation and the great thing about the pure world.

Exploring the Genres The place Birds Take Flight

Birds, with their inherent symbolism of freedom, perspective, and generally, hazard, have lengthy captivated filmmakers, offering wealthy thematic materials throughout a various spectrum of genres. From the whimsical flights of animated characters to the ominous presence of feathered predators in thrillers, birds provide a singular lens by means of which to discover human experiences, anxieties, and aspirations. Their portrayal varies considerably relying on the style, reflecting the narrative wants and thematic targets of every movie.

Style-by-Style Examination

Filmmakers creatively make use of birds, reworking them into characters or symbols, to form the narrative. Animated movies incessantly make the most of birds as protagonists, sidekicks, or sources of humor. Thrillers usually make use of birds to generate suspense and worry, whereas dramas use them to discover themes of isolation, loss, or freedom.Animated movies, akin to Disney’s

  • Discovering Nemo* (2003) which options seagulls, and Pixar’s
  • Up* (2009) with Kevin the hen, incessantly anthropomorphize birds, giving them human-like traits and personalities. These movies usually leverage birds for comedic aid, emotional resonance, and to propel the plot ahead. The animation model itself can significantly affect the notion of the birds; vivid, colourful designs and exaggerated options contribute to a lighthearted tone, whereas extra real looking or stylized animation can add to a way of marvel or hazard.

Within the thriller style, birds can develop into harbingers of doom or devices of terror. Alfred Hitchcock’sThe Birds* (1963) is a first-rate instance, the place birds are remodeled from innocent creatures right into a menacing drive of nature. The movie makes use of close-up pictures of birds’ eyes, sharp sounds of flapping wings, and the sudden nature of their assaults to create a palpable sense of dread.

The birds should not essentially given particular person personalities however act as a collective risk, representing primal fears and the breakdown of societal order.Dramas incessantly use birds as symbols of freedom, resilience, or confinement.The Painted Fowl* (2019) is a harrowing instance of a movie utilizing birds to characterize the cruel realities of warfare. The movie doesn’t have particular hen characters however employs the presence of birds to characterize innocence and fragility in opposition to a brutal backdrop.

The usage of birds in drama may also evoke emotions of nostalgia, loss, or the passage of time, usually mirrored within the visible symbolism.

Style Fowl Portrayal Narrative Operate Thematic Parts
Animated Typically anthropomorphized, with human-like traits and personalities. Function protagonists, sidekicks, or sources of comedic aid; drive the plot ahead. Themes of friendship, braveness, overcoming adversity, and the significance of household.
Thriller Typically depicted as menacing and unpredictable, representing a primal risk. Generate suspense, create worry, and symbolize the breakdown of order or management. Themes of paranoia, the fragility of civilization, and the ability of nature.
Drama Symbolic, representing freedom, resilience, isolation, or loss. Replicate character arcs, evoke emotional responses, and supply visible metaphors. Themes of freedom, confinement, the passage of time, and the human situation.

Filmmakers generally use particular narrative units and thematic parts when that includes birds. The symbolism of flight, representing freedom, escape, or aspiration, is a pervasive ingredient. Sound design, together with the sounds of wings, calls, and the absence of sound, is essential in establishing the tone and enhancing the emotional affect. Shut-up pictures, significantly of eyes or beaks, can amplify the sense of hazard or vulnerability.

The usage of these parts isn’t arbitrary; it is a calculated effort to deepen the viewers’s engagement with the narrative.

Moreover, the setting performs a vital function. Open skies and huge landscapes can amplify the sense of freedom, whereas enclosed areas can heighten emotions of confinement. The juxtaposition of birds with human characters and settings creates layers of which means, permitting filmmakers to discover advanced themes and elicit a variety of feelings. The usage of birds in filmmaking, due to this fact, isn’t just about portraying avian creatures however about leveraging their inherent symbolism to complement the storytelling expertise.

The Artwork of Fowl-Impressed Visuals

The visible language employed in movies that includes birds is paramount to their storytelling prowess. Cinematography, the artwork of movement image pictures, serves as the first instrument for translating the inherent magnificence, drama, and symbolism of avian life onto the display screen. Mastering methods like digital camera angles, lighting, and particular results permits filmmakers to craft compelling narratives and evoke deep emotional responses from audiences.

Capturing Fowl Actions and Behaviors, Finest films of birds

The power to showcase the dynamic actions and complex behaviors of birds is a trademark of outstanding hen cinematography. The problem lies in capturing the pace, grace, and unpredictability of those creatures whereas additionally conveying their interactions with their environment. Filmmakers make use of a wide range of methods to attain this.

  • Excessive-Velocity Images: That is essential for showcasing the fast actions of birds, such because the flapping of wings throughout flight or the swift strikes of a predator. Excessive-speed cameras seize these moments in beautiful element, revealing nuances usually unseen by the bare eye.
  • Telephoto Lenses: These lenses enable cinematographers to seize close-up pictures of birds from a distance, minimizing disturbance to their pure conduct and enabling intimate views of their options and expressions.
  • Monitoring Pictures: Following birds in flight or on the bottom with a shifting digital camera provides a way of immersion and permits viewers to expertise their actions from a singular perspective.
  • Time-Lapse Images: This method condenses prolonged intervals into shorter sequences, revealing patterns of conduct, akin to nest-building or migration, that will in any other case be troublesome to look at.

Cinematic Strategies for Enhanced Storytelling

Cinematography performs a pivotal function in amplifying the narrative and emotional affect of bird-centric movies. It goes past mere documentation, actively shaping the viewer’s notion and expertise.

Listed below are 5 memorable scenes the place hen cinematography was pivotal:


1. “The Birds” (1963):
The escalating rigidity in Alfred Hitchcock’s masterpiece is considerably enhanced by the unsettling digital camera angles and close-ups of the birds, particularly throughout their assaults. The gradual build-up, coupled with strategically positioned pictures of birds gathering, creates a way of dread and impending doom.


2. “Winged Migration” (2001):
This documentary depends closely on breathtaking aerial cinematography to comply with the migration patterns of varied hen species. The digital camera’s perspective, usually mimicking the birds’ flight, gives an immersive expertise and emphasizes the size and great thing about the journey.


3. “Rio” (2011):
The colourful animation of “Rio” is delivered to life by means of dynamic digital camera actions that seize the power and pleasure of the macaws. The usage of vivid colours, dynamic angles, and fluid animation throughout the flight sequences creates a visually stimulating expertise.


4. “Free Willy” (1993):
Though primarily centered on a whale, the movie contains poignant scenes of a bald eagle interacting with the protagonist. The eagle’s flight, captured with sweeping digital camera pictures in opposition to the backdrop of the ocean, symbolizes freedom and connection.


5. “March of the Penguins” (2005):
The cinematography on this documentary focuses on the perseverance and resilience of penguins within the Antarctic. Shut-ups of their struggles in opposition to the cruel setting, coupled with broad pictures showcasing the vastness of their habitat, evoke empathy and admiration.

Lighting, Digital camera Angles, and Particular Results

The skillful manipulation of lighting, digital camera angles, and particular results is prime to creating visually beautiful representations of birds. These methods not solely improve the aesthetic enchantment but in addition serve to amplify the emotional resonance of the scenes.

  • Lighting: Lighting is essential for setting the temper and highlighting the birds’ options. Mushy, pure lighting can be utilized to showcase their magnificence, whereas dramatic lighting might be employed to create suspense or emphasize their energy.
  • Digital camera Angles: Low-angle pictures could make birds seem majestic and highly effective, whereas high-angle pictures can present a way of vulnerability or isolation. The selection of digital camera angle significantly influences the viewer’s notion of the birds.
  • Particular Results: Strategies akin to gradual movement, movement blur, and CGI can be utilized to boost the visible affect of hen actions. These results can create a way of awe, drama, and even humor, relying on the context. For instance, CGI can be utilized to realistically depict a hen’s intricate feather actions throughout flight.
See also  Best 2026 Federal Pay Raise Navigating the Complexities and Projections

Behind the Scenes: The Challenges and Triumphs of Fowl-Themed Filmmaking: Finest Films Of Birds

Best movies of birds

Bringing the sweetness and majesty of birds to the large display screen isn’t any simple feat. Filmmakers face a singular set of hurdles, from the unpredictability of avian conduct to the advanced logistics of filming in numerous and infrequently difficult environments. Capturing the essence of those creatures whereas guaranteeing their security and the integrity of the storytelling requires revolutionary options, meticulous planning, and a deep understanding of each animal conduct and filmmaking methods.

The method is a testomony to the dedication and creativity of these concerned, usually leading to cinematic experiences that captivate and encourage.

Navigating the Obstacles

The journey of crafting a bird-themed movie is fraught with difficulties, demanding a mix of technical experience, endurance, and moral concerns. The challenges lengthen past merely pointing a digital camera at a hen; they embody a big selection of things that may considerably affect the ultimate product. These vary from the practicalities of working with reside animals to the complexities of incorporating visible results and adhering to stringent animal welfare pointers.To raised perceive these complexities, let’s discover some particular challenges filmmakers encounter:

  • Working with Dwell Birds: The unpredictable nature of reside birds poses a continuing problem. Their actions, behaviors, and reactions to the setting are sometimes troublesome to regulate, requiring in depth planning and adaptation. Coaching birds for particular actions is a time-consuming course of that calls for experience and a deep understanding of avian psychology.
  • Animal Welfare Rules: Adhering to strict animal welfare pointers is paramount. Filmmakers should make sure the birds’ well being, security, and well-being all through the manufacturing course of. This contains offering applicable habitats, vitamin, and veterinary care, in addition to minimizing stress and guaranteeing moral remedy.
  • Logistical Complexities of Filming in Numerous Environments: Fowl-themed movies usually require filming in varied places, from dense forests and open skies to coastal areas and concrete landscapes. Every setting presents distinctive challenges, together with climate circumstances, accessibility, and the potential for wildlife interference.
  • Incorporating CGI and Visible Results: When actual birds can not carry out sure actions or are impractical to movie, filmmakers usually depend on CGI. Seamlessly integrating these results with live-action footage requires superior technical abilities and a eager eye for element to create plausible and visually beautiful outcomes.
  • Capturing Genuine Fowl Conduct: Precisely depicting hen conduct is essential for realism and viewers engagement. This requires in depth analysis into hen species, their habits, and their interactions with the setting. Filmmakers should attempt to seize genuine moments that resonate with viewers.
  • Coordinating with Fowl Handlers and Trainers: Profitable bird-themed filmmaking depends closely on the experience of hen handlers and trainers. They play an important function in coaching birds, managing their welfare, and guaranteeing their cooperation throughout filming. Efficient communication and collaboration between filmmakers and these specialists are important.

Filmmakers have developed revolutionary options to beat these obstacles.

One notable instance is the usage of remote-controlled robotic birds, which might mimic the actions of actual birds, permitting for exact management and minimizing the necessity for reside animal involvement.

One other strategy entails leveraging superior CGI know-how to create real looking hen characters and environments, decreasing the reliance on filming in difficult circumstances. Moreover, meticulous pre-production planning, together with in depth location scouting, detailed storyboarding, and thorough threat assessments, is essential for minimizing potential issues and guaranteeing a clean manufacturing course of. These options have considerably impacted the ultimate product, leading to extra real looking, moral, and visually compelling movies that commemorate the sweetness and marvel of birds.

Concluding Remarks

In conclusion, one of the best films of birds showcase the exceptional means of cinema to seize the sweetness, drama, and complexity of the avian world. From early experiments to fashionable masterpieces, filmmakers have constantly pushed artistic boundaries, using know-how and artistry to carry these creatures to life. The enduring enchantment of bird-themed movies lies not solely of their visible splendor but in addition within the narratives they weave, reminding us of the marvel of nature and the ability of storytelling.

This exploration demonstrates the ability of cinema and the enduring attract of our feathered mates, leaving an enduring affect on audiences throughout generations.

Frequent Queries

What are a few of the earliest bird-themed movies?

Early examples embrace silent movies like “The Eagle’s Nest” (1913) and “The Birds” (1963), which had been among the many first to characteristic birds prominently.

How has CGI impacted the portrayal of birds in films?

CGI has revolutionized hen portrayals, permitting for real looking flight sequences, numerous species representations, and dramatic results beforehand unimaginable with reside birds or sensible results.

What are the challenges of filming with actual birds?

Challenges embrace animal welfare issues, unpredictable conduct, the necessity for expert trainers, and the logistical difficulties of filming in numerous environments.

Are there any movies that solely characteristic birds as the primary characters?

Sure, many animated movies, like “Rio” (2011) and “Discovering Nemo” (2003) to a sure extent, deal with birds and different marine life.

How do filmmakers guarantee the moral remedy of birds throughout manufacturing?

Filmmakers collaborate with animal trainers, welfare organizations, and comply with strict pointers to make sure the birds’ well being, security, and well-being.

Leave a Comment